It’s ridiculously cold here today and I realized this morning that I cannot for the life of me remember the last time I had spaghetti.
For many years, I was under the impression that spaghetti sauce that didn’t come from a jar or packet mix was the sole domain of little Italian grandmothers. Not so! Last Christmas I manned up and just decided I would make my own – no packet, no jar, just me. And it is good. :) (No, I wouldn’t say it’s as good as Rose Reed’s who taught me how to bake wonderful bread when I was a kid, but I think she’d declare it more than acceptable.)
Now, my recipe doesn’t have mushrooms in it, which some would say is heresy, but I just don’t care for mushrooms in my sauce! However, if you like mushrooms, feel free to add them! I’d think maybe a half cup to a cup of crimini’s would work well, added in when you add the sausage.
Recipe after the jump.

Spaghetti Sauce
1 lb sweet italian sausage (It always ends up a little less, because somehow some of it disappears between the time I cook it and it hits the pot.)
2-3 cloves garlic, finely minced
1/2 c. onion, minced
1-2 6 oz. cans of tomato paste
4-5 8 oz. cans tomato sauce
The sauce & paste can be plain or “italian style”
4-8 oz liquid of your choice (chicken or veg stock, water, red wine, white wine – I find beef stock to be too heavy.)
1 tsp oregano
3/4 tsp basil
1/2 tsp thyme
1-3 cranks of cracked black pepper
1/2 tsp parsley
Cook up the sausage and get it to a “crumbly” state, drain well. (This can be done way ahead of time and popped in the fridge, there will be more than enough simmer time for it to heat all the way through.)
Saute the garlic and onions in a bit of butter or oil, until the onions are soft and translucent.
Add 4 cups of tomato sauce. When you put the first cup in, be ready to stir right away – the pan will be hot and this will prevent burning until the pan temp drops with the additional liquid in it. Then add the rest of the tomato sauce, and work in one can of the tomato paste.
Add in the sausage, heat over medium-low to medium heat until it starts to bubble. Reduce heat to low, cover and let simmer 15 minutes to let the flavors start to come together before adding the additional spices. (Especially if you’re using pre-seasoned tomato sauce or paste – you may need to go lighter on the add’l spices.)
At the 15 minute point, check the consistency – if it’s too thick for your taste, work in some tomato sauce or your “other” liquid – start with 1/2 cup at a time. Too thin? Add tomato paste, starting w/a half can. If you do adjust the liquids or paste, let it go another 5-10 minutes before adding spices.
Once you have the consistency where you like it, add the spices. This is also a good time to start your pasta water – don’t have to get it to boiling just yet, but if you at least get the pot heated up, when you’re ready to cook your pasta, it should only take a few minutes to get it to boiling. (I have a large pot and it does take forever to get water to boil for me.)
Cover and simmer another 15 minutes on low. Check the taste, adjust spices as needed and simmer another 5-10 minutes w/spice adjustment. When you’ve got it where you want it, turn off the heat, fire up the boiling water for the pasta and enjoy! (It will definitely stay hot enough while the pasta is cooking.)
I also use this sauce for lasagna and baked ziti, and it freezes wonderfully.
Once I attempted this with a bay leaf in the mix. Bad idea. Once I realized that was the problem, I managed to salvage it with about 2/3 of a can of tomato paste and some chicken stock and some additional cooking time. Sometimes reversing a disaster is just as satisfying as getting it all right the first time. :)
I’m Italian (though not a grandmother yet, thank goodness!) and I never put mushrooms in my sauce. I enjoy them sauteed on the side too much to put them in, personally.
Your recipe is not too far off from my own. Sadly, I didn’t learn “traditional” spaghetti sauce from any of my Italian relatives but figured it out on my own They always used tomato puree and cooked it most of the day, but sauce and paste works perfectly for me, though I’m thinking of experimenting with diced tomatoes, just to chunk it up and have some fun with it. Funny, my family LOVES the bay leaf flavor. Oh well, different strokes and all that.
I’ll have to give yours a try sometime. Sounds yummy!